Skip to main content

From "Pack Animal" magazine

Pack Llama Ban In Alaska

Is the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) the first government agency in the United States to ban the pack llama based on the premise that they are a disease risk to wildlife? Having been actively involved when other government agencies have proposed similar bans (over the last 25 years), to the best of my knowledge BLM (Alaska’s Eastern Interior Resource Management Area) is the first to do so. Now that a precedent has been set, other BLM resource management areas in Alaska with wild sheep and goat habitat will likely soon follow with pack llama prohibitions. The danger that we now face is that other government agencies will soon follow BLM’s lead in a domino effect. Could BLM lands in the lower 48 states be next? Will some other government agency in Alaska or the lower 48 be next?

BLM has successfully imposed the prohibition on pack llamas in Alaska’s Fortymile district through their recently signed and approved Eastern Interior Resource Management Plan (RMP). According to BLM, (and per page 1700 of the EIS for the Eastern Interior RMP) the provisions regarding camelids were based largely on the following publications:
1) Garde, E., et al. 2005. Examining the Risk of Disease Transmission between Wild Dall Sheep and Mountain Goats and Introduced Domestic Sheep, Goats, and Llamas in the Northwest Territories.

On page 2 of the above publication it states, “Conversely, contact between llamas and wild Dall’s sheep or goats may result in disease in wild species, but there is insufficient data available to clearly assess the role of camelids as a source of disease at this time (for additional information see Communicable Diseases Risks to Wildlife from Camelids in British Columbia).”
2) Schwantje, et al 2003. Communicable Diseases Risks to Wildlife from Camelids in British Columbia.
On page v of the above publication (Executive Summary) it states “Risks from camelids to wildlife in British Columbia remain hypothetical after this risk assessment, as no direct evidence was found to implicate camelids as sources of significant diseases in wildlife in BC or elsewhere.”

Here are links to the above information and publications:
Fortymile Eastern Interior RMP
EIS for Eastern Interior RMP
2005 Canadian Publication

2003 Canadian Publication

BLM’s decision was not based on fact or science. The basis of the decision for BLM to ban pack llamas are two Canadian publications that pose hypothetical disease risk scenario as readily admitted by the authors. Per Dr. Murray Fowler (world renowned camelid expert) in a letter to the Alaska Department of Fish and Game dated April 9, 2012 (public record) he said that there are errors of interpretation in both of the above Canadian publications that he takes exception to. Llamas are not a reservoir for any infectious disease that may occur in cattle, sheep, goats, or cervids.

BLM has now effectively eliminated a user group based on anecdotal evidence and hypothetical risk scenarios. None of the publications cited by BLM (as the basis of their decision to prohibit pack llamas) provide scientifically defensible evidence of a llama communicable disease risk. These Canadian publications question the conclusions of the most comprehensive collaboration of the vet community to date that found no endemic diseases or transmission to wildlife. Other agencies looked at the science of disease transmission. NPS is almost a zero risk tolerance agency. They looked at the same Canadian studies that BLM based this decision upon but came to a completely different conclusion. For example, pack llamas are welcome in Yellowstone, Glacier, and Rocky Mountain National Parks. They all have sensitive wild sheep and/or goat habitat. Pack llamas are not prohibited in any of Alaska’s National Parks. Rocky Mountain National Park uses llamas for packing and trail maintenance. If you think that you can be of any assistance in this matter (or know anyone that can), please contact me (using the contact form on this page.) Thanks.

by Phil Nuechterlein
Eagle River, Alaska


Popular posts from this blog

Lower Eagle River Trail or River Woods Trail

The lower Eagle River trail (also called the River Woods Trail) runs along the Eagle River in Chugach State Park and can be hiked all times of the year including winter. Often overlooked, it's just minutes from downtown Eagle River. It's an easy walk that offers convenient access with intermittent views of surrounding mountains and opportunity for wildlife viewing.

The trailhead can be accessed from the south side of the Briggs Bridge off the Eagle River Loop Road where there is pubic parking and a boat launch.

From the Briggs Bridge access, the lower Eagle River trail goes east for through birch and spruce forest over relatively flat terrain. The old section of trail skirting the private land has been improved over the years and is now clearly marked. (See photo on left.)  Boardwalks have been added to a marshy section next to the Swan Pond. Remains of charred trees and scorched ground remind us of the wildfire that burned about 25 acres in this area over the Memorial day we…

Hike the Symphony Lake - Ship Creek Loop

Do this hike in September and you will be rewarded with vibrant fall colors! The hike goes through the beautiful South Fork Valley and over the mountains into Ship Creek with stunning views of alpine lakes (Eagle and Symphony), tarns and valleys surrounded by rugged, glaciated mountains.

Download this free DNR South Fork Valley Trail Guide: SF Trail Guide & Map

To get there, take the trail to Eagle and Symphony Lakes from the South Fork trailhead parking lot where there is now a fee station. Alaska State Park Fees. Proceed to the west side of Symphony Lake where there are several camping spots if you decide to camp here for the night. Once on the southwest side of Symphony Lake, look to the mountains directly west for a broad mostly tundra slope with a saddle at the top. After a 1600 foot climb you will reach the saddle where you can see the North Fork of Ship Creek. At this point you can either drop about halfway down to Ship Creek to find an old horse trail. Follow the horse/an…

Hike to the Perch, Heritage Falls and Icicle Creek on the Historic Iditarod Trail

The Historic Iditarod (aka Crow Pass) Trail which spans the Girdwood Valley to Eagle River is considered one of the best trails to hike in the Chugach mountain range and offers diverse scenic sights including glaciers, waterfalls, wildlife. It’s not only a great hiking/backpacking route, but it's also an historic portion of the Iditarod Trail that led from Seward to mines in the Interior. A bit of trivia not known by many is that this trail was rebuilt in the 1970s with girl scout labor.
There are a number of hiking options from the Eagle River Nature Center (ERNC) parking lot. You can hike the entire twenty-three mile traverse, hike portions of the Crow Pass trail (as I often do) or take other shorter trails that start from the ERNC. Follow this link to find out more on these shorter trails. Eagle River Nature Center Trails.

If you elect to hike the entire twenty-three mile traverse you can start from either Girdwood or the ERNC. The Elevation Gain is 2,100 feet from Crow Creek …